Board Thread:Rebirth: Archived Applications/@comment-8914761-20141006011908/@comment-3030647-20141009093334

This methodology doesn't seem to work very well, as Madara did not have the capability to become a reincarnation given that, while his chakra reserves were vast, they simply were not as naturally large as Indra's. Despite the addition of the Shinju's chakra, this would not be permanently placed inside of him and, therefore, his Rinnegan had no chance of passing on. Therefore, I deny this.