Board Thread:Quality Committee/@comment-8914761-20150117182058

I'd like to throw out the way at which I'll be looking over user's articles. Not sure if others would use it, but incase you packed your own way, take mine. Here it is:

My grading works much like the SCQE. Being split into a number of section with each being about the sections needing upgrades. For each section, I use a nifty strategy called "ACES", that I will explain down below. I give a quick entry as to why it should be upgraded. After telling them why, I give them a how. Otherwise known as a "tip". This save us, the hunter-nin, the trouble of having to go back and forward on the talk pages hoping a user sees it. Using this allows you to already have how the user can fix it, now all they have to do is HOPEFULLY abide by your advice.


 * ACES: ACES, is a English strategy which we use at my school. However, my teachers have told me every school within the state of Texas uses it, which is possible. In all honesty, I dislike the strategy when using it on test and in class, however the wikia can benefit greatly from this. Each letter has a different representation, which shall now be laid out as so.


 * A: The A in ACES, means answer. When referring to it in a school way, it means answer. Basically it's saying answer the question, utilizing the question. For example: "What changes, if any, should be made in sentence 47.". You would then answer as: "The changes that should be made in sentence 47 are..." How can I use the A in ACES as a hunter-nin, you may ask. Simple. When we go into reviewing the character, we ask, or should ask; "How can I help increase the quality in EmperorSigma's work?" That is now the question you, if you are using ACES, should ask yourself before judging. Now what you do is look over the article, and you answer your question. "I can help increase EmperorSigma's article by, telling him which sections need work." The A is technically one that you state in your psyche (mind), instead of utilizing it as an immediate way of judging.


 * C: The C in ACES means "Cite your evidence." By citing your evidence, I mean mention where you're finding this stuff. In the C part of ACES, this is where you use direct quotes from the users article. Let me clear on something I don't mean quote quotes, but I mean like direct words from a section. Like let's say you want someone to expand on a sentence but they think you're being a dick. This where C comes into action. Let's say somewhere in the appearance section it's states "Sigma wears a blue outfit." (I got this from Sigma's old section). However, you're trying to tell them they should stray away from less detailed appearances. Then you use a direct quote from the article showing them what SHOULD not NEEDS, but SHOULD be changed.


 * E: The E in ACES means explain. Which is pretty much straight forward and we all do it. I don't see the point of needing to explain the E. (I'm sorry I laugh at that joke for real)


 * S: Finally, the S. The S just means summarize. Summarize what you are saying. A summary can range from anything telling them they could benefit from utilizing your advice, or even shortening their review.

This isn't exactly mandatory, cause who the hell am I? But if you don't have a system to use, this could be taken into consideration for those having nothing to use.

- EmperorLordSigma 