Talk:Murasaki Uchiha/@comment-1399043-20191228173729

Boruto and Sarada are not and cannot be incarnates of Indra and Asura, as their parents who are the incarnates are still alive during their lifetime. That explanation "Murasaki manifested the Rinnegan simultaneously with her Mangekyō Sharingan. She was able to do so because her grandparents were each the reincarnation of Asura Ōtsutsuki and Indra Ōtsutsuki. Murasaki's father inherited both the chakra of Asura and Indra, but the mixed chakra of Hagoromo Ōtsutsuki first appeared with Murasaki." is completely impractical and in my honest opinion a power grab.

Inheriting the chakra is theoretically possible as Boruto and Sarada "could" have inherited a portion of the incarnate chakra from their fathers respectively but adding in the tidbit about having Hagoromo's chakra as well is a red flag as having the individual chakra is one thing again in theory but even Madara who "attained Hagoromo's chakra" by infusing a piece of Hashirama, did not awaken the Rinnegan until near his death, so your character having it instantly "due to genetics" is a far leap.

Please revise.