Board Thread:Fanon Canon 2/@comment-2001574-20140921163723/@comment-6003865-20140923121154

You just defeated your own point ten, he gave them different things.

All it says is that it requires Hago's chakra. until that article says otherwise, which since i doubt Kishi is going to go into the origins of the Rinnegan anymore probably won't happen, i going to go with what canon says.

That being said I am of the opinion that it would be significantly harder to awaken the dojutsu without the EMS.

and no your Kabuto comment does not throw a single thing i said out the window. It can only be conjecture no matter which way you look at it, since it takes multiple transplants in both Madara's and Sasuke's case in order for them to awaken it, with the last one in Sasuke's place being the sage's chakra itself. While Madara's was Madara MAKING the sage's chakra by combining himself with Hashi's dna, which is like magic.

So it took chakra magic and Hashi magic in both cases in order to make the Rinnegan. That does not seem like a straight evolution to me. Evolution doesn't usually require multiple additional materials that the body would never normally have. The MS is an evolution of the sharingan, the EMS is hax to make the MS worthless. However they are all one kekkei genkai.

The Rinnegan is not the same KG due to the extra materials needed to make it. Ones that the Uchiha DO NOT possess.