Board Thread:Guides & Idea Board/@comment-2089817-20151120231810/@comment-5004454-20151121092303

I know I'm new and all, but I found this idea interesting. Granted, I also agree with some points on either side, so with enough fine tuning, it can work. Quite smoothly, I might add. These are just my own opinions, not a universal law.

1/ You guys would need more people to help overlook this project and user articles. One piece wiki for example has a ton of people managing it. Add chunin, jonin, ANBU maybe? Idk, it's up to you.

2/ Byte system could be combined with completion of specific content (appearance, personality, abilities etc). Say, first degree should have a character that has at least the appearance, personality and ability section done. Maybe dig into the canon requirements for each shinobi rank. We know for example that Jonin need at least 2 elemental affinities to be qualified for promotion.

3/ Make it optional. Imo, as Sei said, people mostly come here for recognition. Mostly, and all of them make Uchiha, Senju, Otsutsuki characters. So I'm sure they would love to rise in rank and would deffinitely come to you, rather than you having to patrol the site. Give various bonuses to each degree, whether it is something small, but convenient or large and flashy, and you won't have to do much, other than judge the quality of articles.

These are the most fundamental aspects that hamper this idea in my opinion.