Board Thread:Fanon Canon 2/@comment-2089817-20140922021242/@comment-6003865-20140922050134

you mean the one that says she was the 10 tails, and got split up into the beasts?

you are picking and choosing how you use your justifications for characters sei.

You guys say that it was asura's and indra's chakra that was possessing people, aka the whole transmigrant. except here all of her chakra was sealed into the tailed bests. So by that definition, her "transmigrants" are the tailed beasts.

The Sage of the Six Paths, Hagoromo Ōtsutsuki, seems to suggest that only powerful chakras—such as his sons, Asura and Indra—can remain behind after the deaths of their hosts.

^direct from your article Ten.

Her chakra was split and sealed, this process wouldn't work.

However you now bring in her soul and everything. Which was never even mentioned in your normal bit of transmigrancy. You also mention that hago, who has been confirmed as residing in the pure land, and even kept a lot of chakra, as evidenced by helping naruto and sasuke out. Even helping naruto to make a mini-shinju which probably could not have happened if he hadn't kept most, if not all, of his chakra.

As for the mind body soul thing, i'm just pointing out that you could easilydefine the one that possessed madara, which contained every part of kaguya, as the real kaguya resurrected.

Next, black zetsu. The guy was purely in the background throughout history. merely watching. It states that he manipulated the uchiha through the modified tablet. It didn't make an actual move until the moment of summoning for kaguya, instead pretending to be madara's will once it finally came out of the shadows. Therefore hago randomly deciding to reincarnate, when the Canon shows that he was still a ghost being, makes zero sense.

I have a couple more issues, but i'll leave it at this for the moment.